
Dr. Michael Sugrue's Archive
Remarks on Islamic history, from an unfinished history of the world.
The polyglot Persian Empire had been conquered early in the expansion of Islam, and the traditional Persian advantage of serving as a complex cultural bridge between east and west was inherited by Islam. There is a very disproportionate number of Persians among the great figures in Islamic thought. Al-Khwarizimi, Al-Kindi, Al Razi, Al-Farabi, Avicenna, Al-Ghazali, Al-Tusi and many other Persian Moslems were eminent scholars.
Mikes LITMUS TEST (below) is an Imaginary historical fact pattern.
Hypothetically, if the government were to announce that it intends to round up all _________ (insert some group of people) and then exterminate these people as quickly and completely as practically possible, not for anything specific that they have individually done but for who they are in general,
MY QUESTION FOR PHILOSOPHERS IS THIS:
Can you think of any moral reason why our government should refrain from doing this?
Great Postcolonial Epics:
Africa
Latin America
Derek Walcott Omeros, searching for a way to “enter that light beyond metaphor”[1]
Compare Che with American Teddy Roosevelt.
Both were born into wealthy well connected families which had the resources to fund higher education, Che at the University of Buenos Aires, TR at Harvard college. Both were sickly boys who struggled with debilitating asthma, but embraced an active life nonetheless. TR was interested in animals as a boy, Che was very fond of poetry.
CERVANTES, DQ I. 1605 II. 1615
1547-1616 1571 WOUNDED AT LEPANTO
CAPTIVE 1575-1580
FIRST GREAT NOVEL = COMIC MOCK EPIC
WINDMILLS, ATTACK ON FLOCK SHEEP, VIGIL 10
COURTYARD OF INN, BARBER BASIN = MAGIC HELMET
MADMAN AS HERO, NOBLE, ENTHUSIASTIC, DELUDED ALTER EGO, SIMPLE, PROSAIC, REALISTIC ANTI HERO CERVANTES : SANCHO :: SPANISH CULTURE : DQ
I.
AUTHOR’S PREFACE DIFFICULT -> FRIEND SAYS INSERT RANDOM LATIN PHRASES + FOOTNOTE + BIBLE “PURE NATURE YOUR BUSINESS”… -> DESTROY ROMANCES CHAP I ALONZO QUIXANO -> CRAZY BECAUSE OF CHIVALRIC ROMANCES BECOMES KNIGHT ERRANT CREATES IMAGINARY WORLD ROSINANTE, DULCINEA=DQ CHAP II MYTHIC INFLATION, INN=CASTLE, SALT FISH/MOLDY BREAD=GREAT FOOD, PROSTITUTES WAIT ON HIM = GREAT NOBLE LADIES CHAP 4 INNKEEPER AGREES TO DUB DQ, VIGIL = 2HRS DQ BATTLES MEN WATERING MULES, NEWLY DUBBED DQ COMES UPON MAN BEATING APPRENTICE SHEPHERDS DQ RESCUES, LEAVES, BOY BEATEN MORE DEMANDS MERCHANTS RECOGNIZE DULCINEA’S BEAUTY, ASKED FOR PIC, HE CHARGES, FALLS, AND IS BEATEN AND LEFT IN ROAD CHAP 8 TILTING AT WINDMILLS, MAGICIAN TURNS GIANTS INTO WINDMILLS, DQ IS THROWN, SANCHO HELPS UP NEXT DAY DQ MISTAKES MONKS FOR NECROMANCERS, SANCHO DESPOILS MONK + IS BEATEN, DQ PRESENTS HIMSELF TO LADY IN CARRIAGE, HER GENTLEMAN FIGHTS SYMBOLISM: OUTDATED INSTITUTIONS, IDEAS, TRADITIONS II.
DESCARTES, DISCOURSE ON METHOD 1637 IN FRENCH
OPTICS, METEORS, ANALYTIC GEOMETRY
1 SKEPTICISM AS A METHOD OF CERTAINTY
2 RULES OF METHOD
ONLY ACCEPT CLEAR + DISTINCT IDEAS MAXIMUM DIVISION OF PARTS (ANALYSIS) SIMPLEST TO MOST COMPLEX COMPLETE ENUMERATIONS 3 MORALS + MAXIMS WHILE CONDUCTING METHOD
MODERATION, NEVER QUESTION FAITH
GALILEO TO BE AVOIDED
HELIOCENTRISM CONDEMNED
4 PROOF OF SELF, GOD, REASON -> FINITE FALLIBLE IMPERFECT
JE PENSE DONC JE SUIS NON VACUOUS CONTRAST
CAMUS 1913-1960 ?NOT EXISTENTIALIST
EMBRACES ABSURDITY, REJECTS NIHILISM
ANARCHISM, PACIFISM, ANTI-COLONIALISM (ALGERIA)
OXYMORONIC MEANING OF THE MEANINGLESS (DEATH)
ETHIC OF “AUTHENTICITY” [KIERKEGAARD + NIETZSCHE]
AESTHETE -> CONTRA CAPITAL PUNISHMENT
THE PLAGUE 1947 HEROIC COMMITTMENT
THE REBEL 1951
SOURCE OF HUMAN SOLIDARITY = METAPHYSICAL
ADOLESCENT REJECTION OF AUTHORITY PROMETHEUS
REJECTS SARTRE + STALIN
HEROIC DEFIANCE OF “OPPRESSION” BY VIOLENCE
THE STRANGER 1942 “MOTHER DIED TODAY. DR MAYBE YESTERDAY. I CANT BE SURE.
HOBBES 1588-1679 LEVIATHAN 1651
TRANSLATES THUCYDIDES KING OF THE PROUD
ENGLISH CIVIL WAR SENSE->REASON/SPEECH
DESIRING MACHINES
1 HUMAN NATURE = MATERIALISM/MECHANISM
MAN = PARTICLES IN MOTION
AUTOMATA WITH
SELF DEFEATING,
SELF CONTRADICTORY PROGRAMMING
LIFE = MOTION, DESIRES INFINITE TO DEATH
HUMANS DRIVEN BY PRIDE + FEAR
REASON = MANIPULATION OF NAMES NO METAPHOR
TRUTH = CORRECT ORDERING OF NAMES
ALL PURSUE HONOR/SUPERIORITY -> ENVY/ WAR
2 THE COMMONWEALTH = ARTIFICIAL MORTAL GOD
AESCHYLUS (534-456) DISTINGUISHED AT MARATHON
ORESTEIN (458) FIRST PRIZE
DIONYSIA -> CHORUS MUSIC+SONG+DANCE
CURSE ON HOUSE OF ATREUS
PIETY TOWARD HOMERIC GODS
CASSANDRA STORY
COUNCIL OF AREOPAGUS STRIPPED OF ALL POWERS EXCEPT HOMICIDE COURT
PROBLEM INSOLUBLE BY TRADITIONAL VENDETTA
AGAMEMNON ->WATCHMAN
AG+CASSANDRA MURDERED BY CLYTEMNESTRA
AEGISTHUS GETS REVENGE
DAD, THESTES ATE 2 SONS
TRICKED BY BROTHER ATREUS (AG FATHER)
RED CARPET -> FOR GODS, NOT HUMANS
CASSANDRA THROWS DOWN STAFF/WREATH
ARISTOTLE, POLITICS PICKS UP FROM N.C.
BERKER SECTION NUMBERS TELOS = VIRTUOUS CITIZENS
EUDAIMONIA
1 POLIS = HIGHEST FORM OF COMMUNITY, ≠ VILLAGE, = NATURAL
NATURAL SLAVERY, LIVING TOOLS
WOMEN SUBORDINATE ≠ HOUSEHOLDERS, CHILDREN SUBORDINATE
TO PARENTS
TELOS OF HOUSEHOLD = VIRTUE OF WIFE/CHILDREN
2 BEST REGIME CRITICIZES REPUBLIC + LAWS, PROPERTY?
EXAMINES: SPARTAN, CRETAN, CATHIGINIAN
VIRTUES: INTELLECTUAL + MORAL
TAUGHT HABIT
3 CITIZENSHIP = ABILITY TO PARTICIPATE IN ADMINISTRATION